7 Comments
Apr 8Liked by Matthew Sitman

I’m guessing your mystery man is the Village Voice writer J. Hoberman…

Expand full comment
Apr 8Liked by Matthew Sitman

Yes, agreed! came here to say that.

Expand full comment
author

Yes! Thank you! I couldn't tell whether it was Hoberman or Haberman, appreciate the in put.

Expand full comment

I wonder if the lawyer named Howard Meyer, whom the Argosy card describes as a “constitutional attorney”, is Howard N. Meyer. He wrote a book on the 14th Amendment in the 1970s and had been a Special Assistant to US Attorney General Francis Biddle (who held that position during WWII).

Source: https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0967010693024002016

Expand full comment

This an incredible document.. just to see someone wrestle with herself like this, with absolutely no self-awareness… it’s remarkable. Thanks for sharing. Love the Argosy shout out too. That’s a really special place

Expand full comment

I was struck by this during the episode on Decter and reminded again today in reading the letter: her position is completely emotivist. She "feels" (with increasing intensity), she "felt"; they will "suffer"; they will "hate themselves more." And she asserts her consequentialist claims with no evidence--or in the face of massive counter-evidence. I don't think this is unique to her, among her neo-con confreres.

Expand full comment

Hilarious. Thanks for sharing.

Expand full comment